EDITED FOR EMPHASIZED HARSHNESS. HAPPY!?
So I've seen this journal idea on a few profiles I've visited and decided I'd have a go at it.
20.
Sonata Arctica
Except for two songs, I don't listen to these guys anymore, but one thing I never liked about them was simply the lyrics for 90% of their songs. Way too cheesy, and a few lines just make no sense.
19.
Machinae Supremacy
Rob's vocals tend to sound overly ridiculous or whiny in some songs. Also they abuse the SID effects in most of their songs, which I simply hate. Lyrics are good, the music gets somewhat annoying after a while though.
18.
In Flames
Went from absolutely amazing (Clayman / The Jester Race) to absolutely shite (Come Clarity). How they could possibly drop that much in terms of quality and musical integrity still baffles me. R.I.P In Flames. Take This Life is a terrible, terrible, TERRIBLE song.
17.
Hitoshi Sakimoto
Too much of his work just sounds the same. Also the FFXII soundtrack was pretty unremarkable, sounds like something you'd find in a Disney movie, not a FF game.
16.
Megadeth
New album feels like Dave is trying to shove his political views down the listener's throat. Also his vocals can get
extremely irritating sometimes. Also the guy's just flat-out creepy-looking.
15.
Emperor
The vocals in "In the Nightside Eclipse" get drowned out far too much. I thought so when I first heard the album and I still think so. Also asides from the song "With Strength I Burn", Anthems lacks any distinguishing songs and they all just end up sounding way too similar to one another.
14.
Windir
Parts of "1184" are borderline techno...That's really all I got, much love for Windir.
13.
Behemoth
Vocals on "Demigod" sound overly layered and "The Apostasy" wasn't as great as I was hoping it'd be. Nergal's Forehead should start it's own band, that thing's a beast.
12.
Drudkh
Questionable political views (Which I couldn't give two shits about), and the fact that I don't understand a thing that's being said. Curse my lacking knowledge of foreign languages! No other negative points come to mind.
11.
Tool
For one, Tool fans are some of the most annoying bastards on this site. Regarding music, "10,000 Days" wasn't as good as most people made it out to be. The Pot puts me to sleep, the whole song just grates on my nerves.
10.
Black Sabbath
A few mediocre albums, especially "Forbidden".
9.
Mercyful Fate
King Diamond sounds like a clown on helium and crack-cocaine. (Though I'm not completely sure that's a bad thing...) Also a few unimpressive songs and albums, specifically "Into the Unknown". Just downright bad songwriting, there's nothing more to be said.
8.
Katatonia
Some of the newer stuff can be viewed as "emo", though I have no problem with it personally.
7.
Trans-Siberian Orchestra
Some of the vocals on the Beethoven album just sound odd, the song Misery for example. Also too many Christmas-themed albums...I also look like I have a screw loose playing it during the Summer. And they're taking their sweet time with "Nightcastle"...Any year now.
6.
Iron Maiden
"A Matter of Life and Death" wasn't that great compared to their previous albums. Also, for the most part, their songs all follow the same structure, gets kind of predictable and boring after a while. They've also released far too many "Best of" compilations, most of which in fact lack their best songs. How ironic.
5.
Hypocrisy
Peter's vocals sound off on a few songs, and "Catch 22" is a relatively boring album. They've got a good deal of just unremarkable work like the "Abducted" album. Meeeh.
4.
Agalloch
...Um...Uhhhhh...Well, for one, I can't sta- *tosses smoke grenade*
3.
Opeth
"Damnation" is somewhat boring compared to their heavier work, same with "Ghost Reveries" when compared to the godliness of "Blackwater Park".
2.
Nobuo Uematsu
The fact that some people can't appreciate the music because it's "Video game music". Also the FFIX soundtrack has a lot of so-so tracks.
1.
Akira Yamaoka
The Silent Hill soundtrack. It's an excellent soundtrack in the context of the game, so it fulfills its purpose, but can't really listen to it outside of the game, just sounds like racket with the exception of three or four tracks.. Also, I don't particularily care much for the Silent Hill 4 soundtrack.