-
-
pkbarbiedoll
Oh, so that's what gothic is. I assumed all of those "Top Artists" were nu-metal (except the cure).
Ações
-
-
danzborin
So is it possible to apply some sort of editorial wisdom to whether some of there artists actually are Gothic? There seems to be a good consensus that MM, Evanescence, HIM, and Nightwish don't really make sense. Possibly just weighting them lower because other tags are more popularly applied to them? Otherwise, this page isn't terribly useful.
Ações
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
psycaffeine
related band called Psychotica is back, enjoy : ) http://es.youtube.com/watch?v=qO7Ay8QZv_A http://es.youtube.com/watch?v=amQDDq7dUVA&feature=related
Ações
-
Leyasu
@Phunting: The tag isnt just for music related to or inspired by goth music. The word Goth and the word Gothic actually mean different things, its only their similar spelling and the difficulty involved in learning English for non-native English speakers that causes the problem. As such, anything belonging to any of the 5 listed tags belongs on this one. Appreciated, the tagging system isnt great and i will attach note to it alike that of [tag]gothic metal[/tag] to elaborate on this point.
Ações
-
Phunting
@ Dai6kan. I'm sure other can answer you better, but of the top ten tagged I'd say only Dead can Dance and Sisters of Mercy were goth. The Cure and Joy Division are proto-goth really, they influenced the genre but aren't in it as such. Try listening to those anyway and compare to the likes of Mason and the others to see the difference. (I don't know Lacrimosa so can't comment on them)...
Ações
-
runforafall
maybe you're right ad_aeternum, at the moment i dont even know what is gothic. in fact i hate to tag bands.
Ações
-
ad_aeternum
La musica es subjetiva, seguramente marilyn no es gothic, pero para algunos the rasmus es gotico, ni siquiera him me parece gotico pero al final cada uno pensara lo que le parece, no hay verdad absoluta
Ações
-
runforafall
LOL, HIM GOTHIC!???!!! that's shit imo, him it's not even metal, but i still like them. and i dont listen to gothic music but they're all tagged as 'gothic'
Ações
-
-
-
tur0k2
Evanescence? Nightwish? Marilyn Manson? Joy Division?!? 1º. If singer is a girl DO NOT HAVE TO BE A GOTH BAND 2ºJoy Division belongs to post-punk movement and first darkwave scene. 3ºMarilyn Manson was a rockstar, and then he experiments with nu-metal and industrial sounds 4ºNightwish is a POWER\SYMPHONIC METAL BAND PD: sorry for my english
Ações
-
-
-
-
Stuart_Stuartia
The shit people call gothic these days... WOW. I'm not surprised to see Marilyn Manson on that list, but seriously... Marilyn Manson was never gothic. And I wont even go into Nightwish and Evanesence...
Ações
-
-
-
-
-
-
Esta mensagem está indisponível.
-
MissVampyr
to Tipheret: you really need to know whats the meaning of goth. 'that's what my friends that shop at Hot topic and listen to HIM and Evanescence say, so I know it must be true!' Your friends are a complete idiot! tell me which REAL goths who listens to REAL goth music shops at Hot Topic???? Hot Topic is for emos and Mall-Goths (Mall-Goth: The scorn of the Goth Subculture. These are people who are created out of the mislabeling of bands as Goth over the years. They usually listen to a string of non-Goth Rock bands, and are arrogant towards the fact that their music isn't actually Gothic. The name was coined due to their tendency to hang out in shopping malls and shop at mall outlets such as Hot Topic & Blue Banana. "He wears Tripp pants, listens to Marilyn Manson and calls them a Goth band. What a Mall-Goth." )
Ações
-
-
-
-
Morbid_Lolita
Werblack, I agree. Evanescence is 100% Not gothic in the least, neither is Lacuna Coil or Within Temptation. They got it out of whack o.O
Ações
-
Tipheret
Of course it is! that's what my friends that shop at Hot topic and listen to HIM and Evanescence say, so I know it must be true! I'm not going to believe those morons that listen to shit like [artist]Fields of the Nephilim[/artist] or [artist]Siouxie and the banshees[/artist], they don't know what real goth is.
Ações
-
Diego_Evanescen
Tipheret: OK, it continues in that thought that you are going far. Goth is not to use black and to fake that has depression.
Ações