Re-recorded (cover) versions of songs hitting the Top-40 chart is nothing new. Since the inception of the Top-40, certain songs have been recorded every few years, usually in a new and more modern style, by a new (or even old) artist and often they chart again.
But, you may not have known that there are
many instances where the same song, recorded by different artists, has hit the chart in the
same year. In fact, this has happened so many times that we are going to narrow our discussion to songs that have hit the chart in the same year (or within a short period of time) to instances where it has happened
three times or more, lest this discussion would linger too long. As is, this will be a multi-part post.
Most instances of this occurrence took place in the 1950's, but not all. Far too often, a song would be released, and many other artists would record it at once. Never mind waiting 10 years or so to try the song again. In many cases, these songs were on the charts
at the same time!
We'll work through these in alphabetical order. (Note that last.fm does not properly detect some of these artist/title combinations causing the formatting to look incorrect in places.)
The song
Abraham, Martin And John is a tribute to Abraham Lincoln, Martin Luther King, and John and Robert Kennedy. In 1968
Dion pushed the song to #4. The following year,
The Miracles hit #33 with the song, black comedian
Moms Mabley hit #35 (at the age of 75!), and
Tom Clay worked the song into a medley that peaked at #8. So, in 1968 and 1969, the song appeared on the Top-40
four times.
In 1957 the song
Around The World In 80 Days was a popular radio player. Recorded as
Around the World it peaked at #12.
(Main Theme) Around The World peaked at #13. The song was from the movie
Around The World In 80 Days. Also from the movie, the only vocal version of the song was
Around The World.
The Ballad Of Davy Crockett was a popular song in 1955 - apparently too popular as it was a hit four times.
Bill Hayes, an actor and singer, hit #1 with the song and stayed there for
five weeks.
Tennessee Ernie Ford pushed the song to #5 during the same time frame, but he was not the only one. Also at the same time,
Fess Parker, who would later play Daniel Boone on television pushed the song to #5, and
The Voices of Walter Schumann hit #14. All versions of the song were on the chart at the same time, and all were featured on the television series
Disneyland.
Up next is a look at a song that hit the chart
six times in the same year. The song
Banana Boat (Day-O) did it in 1957. Here are the artists that recorded it;
The Banana Boat Song (#9),
Banana Boat (Day-O) (#5),
The Banana Boat Song (#13),
The Banana Boat Song (#18),
The Banana Boat Song (#19), and
Banana Boat (Day-O) (#25) did a comedy version of the song. One would think that the same song as a hit six times in the same year would have made radio listening quite borning.
Earth Angel was good for 3 hits in 1956. Canadian group
The Crew-Cuts used the song as their first hit and pushed it to #3. One-hit wonder group
The Penguins could only get the song as high as #8, and female singer
Gloria Mann fared even less-well at #18 with her version. The song was back in 1986 when
New Edition peaked at #21 (with the most annoying version).
Eddie My Love was also a hit three times in 1956.
The Fontane Sisters pushed the song to #1 and
The Chordettes and
Teen Queens both reached #14 with their versions.
We all know
Eleanor Rigby from 1966. But, did you know that the song was also a hit in 1968 and 1969? First
Ray Charles recording of the song touched the chart at #35 in 1968 and then
Aretha Franklin nearly pushed the song as high as the Beatles' version. She peaked at #17 in 1969. The Beatles' version had peaked at #11 in 1966.
(More to follow...)