Indie_Buttons escreveu:

hmm...yeah, i reckon you guys are being harsh on red. its not as good as 'through the window pane', thats obvious straight away, but there's still something there. the fact that three tracks from red fall in the top ten most played on here says that people do appreciate that album. i certainly think its good, even if it seems like a disapointment after the sheer magnificance of 'through the window pane'. if you won't listen to it because its got bad reviews then i think you're foolish...

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Indie_Buttons

PleaseDrinkMilk escreveu:

Found this group looking for bands that 'sound like The Go! Team'. That's quite a stretch, Last.fm! But this is excellent stuff nonetheless. Plan to keep my eyes peeled the next time I go to the record shop.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para PleaseDrinkMilk

Irryco escreveu:

Compared to through the windowpane Red sucks. If you manage to avoid comparing them, it's a good album.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Irryco

LyricallyWaxed escreveu:

I love Through the Windowpane it is a beautiful album, at first I wasn't sure what to make of Red but I really like it. It is different to the Windowpane album but I prefer that than getting bored of someone spilling out exactly the same sound all the time. I think the Guillemots experiment and for me it works.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para LyricallyWaxed

joni_richardson escreveu:

_labrinthe, I wouldn't describe the songs from red as 'beautiful'; the maybe most through the window pane-esque-beautiful songs are still a bit lyrically... CRAP really. Oh, and I didn't realise that Red was the outcome as the whole band working together instead of what was Fyfe's "genius", as they said themselves (bar Fyfe), as through the window pane was his really. Little fact for anyone who's interested. Personally, if it was just Fyfe that made TTWP and the old beauts amazing, I'd be happy for him to pursue a solo career etc etc etc.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para joni_richardson

lastlyido escreveu:

At first listen, I didn't enjoy Red very much. But after listening to it a little bit, it's actually really good. It's different, but amazing. Everyone should definitely give it another try. But yeah I listened to Get Over It and I was highly disappointed... but now that I've listened to the cd in its entirety, everything just flows so smoothly.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para lastlyido

LabTwat escreveu:

tell me your e-mail adress or something and I will send them to you :)

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para LabTwat

Orso88 escreveu:

Someone who tell me how can I find all the b-sides of them?

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Orso88

vasil_kunitsyn escreveu:

Sao Paulo is the best song for me..

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para vasil_kunitsyn

PirateMagpieMoo escreveu:

I borrowed Red from the library (it was the only Guillemots CD they had, pah!!) and I was a bit disappointed with it, but then again I EXPECTED to be, after hearing such bad reviews about it! So I don't know what I would've thought had I listened to it without any kind of expectation... Although 'Take Me Home' is a good track! But yeah, some of the other songs aren't as beautiful/poetic as the ones on Through the Windowpane. Le sigh. But have a listen anyway!

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para PirateMagpieMoo

Ekolod escreveu:

Through the Windowpane is probably one of my personal top 25 records, but I haven't even thought about buying Red. I'm afraid to get as disappointed as everyone else seems to be.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Ekolod

Ginsoakedboy21 escreveu:

Sao Paulo = one of the greatest songs ever, by anyone. Sadly, Red = pile of poo.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Ginsoakedboy21

London-Baby escreveu:

great band

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para London-Baby

Maidenrugby escreveu:

Bit different to my normal tastes, but still an amazing band. "We're Here" has to be my favourite.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Maidenrugby

Random_acts escreveu:

Best band in existence today, by quite a way. <3 <3

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para Random_acts

PirateMagpieMoo escreveu:

Ohh.... oh. If The World Ends! So so beautiful!! <3 <3 <3 And to think I only heard of them because Fyfe was on Buzzcocks the other week! XD (btw if it's pronounced the same as the bird, it's gilly-mots :) )

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para PirateMagpieMoo

_labyrinthe escreveu:

Red doesn't suck, not in my opinion. there are some beautiful songs on the album. it's different, yes. very different from Through the Windowpane. it took me a few listens to recognise the good tunes, but they're definitely there. you just have to give it a change.

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para _labyrinthe

ortodata escreveu:

Me lembra Rolling Stones...

Exibir perfil | Deixar uma mensagem para ortodata