Second of four 2009 summer show reviews: The Rust Belt Imports British Steel!
Cleveland welcomed Judas Priest and Whitesnake this summer! If you've been dying for reviews of the show/tour, you've likely found them elsewhere by now since this is nearly two months after the show, but here are some thoughts and comments, along with the official set lists and some pics and videos in case you haven't seen them directly in the photo library or on the youtube channel.
A lot of Judas Priest fans questioned the pairing of these two bands, since the style of music is different. That certainly is a valid point, particularly if you compare the biggest hits of Judas Priest with the multi-platinum, bombastic Whitesnake hits of the late 80s. And also considering that this Judas Priest tour celebrates the 30th Anniversary of British Steel, while Whitesnake is playing mainly their late 80s hits and only a single song from their latest album, Good to Be Bad. (They are somewhat celebrating a 25th anniversary of Slide It In.)
But if you trace the history and evolution of the bands, I don't think the pairing is all that odd. Give a listen to where David Coverdale began in Deep Purple all those years ago, and the early (best, IMHO) work of Whitesnake, and then listen in comparison with the earlier 70s Judas Priest albums, particularly up through Stained Class - not at all a bad pairing. But I know that's a bit of a stretch for fans of one who aren't fans of the other, especially because neither band plays much of any material from that era live anymore. So I think what this comes down to is that David Coverdale and the JP boys have a mutual respect for each other's longevity and long-running dedication to their craft, and probably make good touring mates at this stage of their games.
Regardless of initial puzzlement, I think the pairing was proven out by the performance, and while there were definitely contigents who were obviously there to see only one of the bands, I think both camps found the other band to great performers.
Whitesnake:
It's true: Whitesnake is basically whomever David Coverdale is working with at any given moment. But this has always been David's band. So part of the judgment has to come down to whether David can still deliver, and part must rest on whatever lineup he has currently assembled.
On the first count, had I posted this immediately after the show, I would have said "mostly." At the time, I would have figured David still has the range, but not enough to last an entire show. He has to conserve himself, sticking to a somewhat lower register than in days of yore and being conservative on the highs. However, in light of the damage he did to his voice and having to drop off the tour later, I'm much more inclined to believe that he's at or nearing the end of his live performance career.
Doctors said that what happened was caught before he could do any permanent damage, but I think the signs are clear: the songs sung as originally performed are going to have to be retired. Unfortunately, that's part of the attraction of the live performance: to hear those legendary songs sung by those legendary pipes. Frankly, though, this isn't 1988 (incidentally, the last time I saw Whitesnake live), and while what you get live is good, it's basically just good enough for how it was played this year: as an opening act. I imagine that David would still be able to at least record new material, since he can work at his own pace and doesn't have to record at the same level he must use when live. But I'm glad that I saw them this time - and we're lucky our show came before the damage - because I suspect that from this point forward, live performances are likely to be limited to Europe.
On the second count, the band is just passable. It's a touring band pretty much of journeymen, and while they can definitely handle the material, there's nothing there that would be an exceptional draw in its own right. Besides seeing David perform, the only real highlight of the set was the guitar solo spotlight, which featured Doug Aldrich and Reb Beach (booed when introduced) trading off solos. Entertaining to watch, but not so awesome that you remember it down the line.
Here's some shots from the show, including a couple of the best DC close-ups for the ladies who didn't have a chance to see them on tour:
Last year's Metal Masters show featured an incredibly good set, and they sounded better than when I had seen them previously on Ozzfest 2004. Could they match last year's performance? On one hand, I am biased by the setlist this year. Whereas last year was a hefty mix of Nostradamus and 80s cuts, this year was the celebration of the 30th anniversary of British Steel, featuring the entire album played in order, and finished off with a trio of late strong cuts and an encore of all-time favorites:
We got a strong visual clue that this would be a classic throwback show right away:
(credit: my buddy SEO)
Rob Halford came onstage and performed the entire British Steel tracklist in denim. I've never seen Halford perform in denim and can't imagine he's worn anything other than leather and steel onstage for 30 years.
Judas Priest continue to defy most signs of aging. They're tight up there on stage: sharp solos, pummeling drums and bass that aren't muddled, and they are always dead on with whatever songs from their massive catalog that they showcase on tour. But I say "most signs" for two reasons. One, to be honest, Rob does seem to be a bit tired at times, though as I said, he can still hit his range. Second, though I'm not complaining about the quality of the set, it was a bit short. They do vary the setlist enough from tour to tour that they can't really be accused of relying on just a core plus one or two more, but as tight as they seem to be, I think we could have got maybe 2-5 more. But it's quibbles. They ARE getting older, and rather than hack through a set longer than they can run for a full tour, they bring a tight set and give us quality over quantity. Judas Priest have always been known for providing a stellar live show, and they're not going to tarnish that reputation. They certainly brought a stellar show here, and they had special reason** to provide Cleveland fans with a most excellent performance!
Here's some additional best shots from the show:
(credit: my buddy SEO)
I close this review with a montage of show pics assembled by SEO:
\m/ (ò_ó) \m/
With this and "Diamonds and Rust", and with The Green Manalishi (With the Two Pronged Crown) last year, I've now completed my own personal experience of my favorite moments from Unleashed in The East, and can cross that off my bucket list!
**Curious side note: if you doubt that Cleveland is a metal town with some of the best metal fans in the world, talk to Jim Bartek and ask him about the special "thumbs up" from Halford near the start of the show!
The idea is to go to the page of your number one artist, and follow the link of it's number one similar artist, then repeating that for this artist and so on, noting down each artist as you go. Do this until you've got to 50 artists. If you get any repeats, just go to the second similar artist or the nearest one that you haven't already had.
Deep Purple / Burn [Live at California Jam, 06 Apr 1974] / Deep Purple: Live in California '74 [DVD] (2) / Jan 2006
This is the second of three posts honoring the 35th Anniversary of California Jam on April 6th, which I failed at the time to highlight.
In the first post, I covered Black Sabbath's peformance. Deep Purple followed them on the California Jam bill. As I mentioned previously, California Jam was not a rock festival that was properly recorded, other than some of it being simulcast on ABC with audio on FM radio. However, unlike Black Sabbath's performance, which has never been released in its entirety, the entire Deep Purple set was finally released on DVD in 2005 as Deep Purple: Live In California '74. (This was actually a re-release of a 1981 laser disc.)
As popular as Black Sabbath were at the time, Deep Purple were monster sellers. And yet, they were also a band in flux, having recently parted ways with Ian Gillan and Roger Glover. Their performance at California Jam was actually the high point of their tour to support Burn, the first album of the Mark III lineup with a 23-year old David Coverdale on vocals and Glenn Hughes on bass and vocals.
Playing to 200,000 people (200,000! festivals in Europe and Latin America still draw that many, but I can't imagine something that huge in the States today!!) was a real baptism of fire, especially for Coverdale, but he and the rest of the band not only handle the pressure, they play one of the all-time storied live sets. (Some of this was previously touched on in the discussion thread for my birthday salute to David Coverdale last Sep 22nd.)
Don't go out of your way to get the DVD or pay more than a few bucks for it, because the quality isn't that great. It would be good to have in your collection of concert films and rock docs if you're like me and have a library of those, but you can watch most of it in an evening online.
This is their opening performance of "Burn" to get you started:
Here is the rest of the Deep Purple setlist for that evening, including five of the songs from Burn: Might Just Take Your Life Lay Down, Stay Down (not included on the original release of the show) Mistreated Smoke On The Water You Fool No One (opened with Lazy and closed out with The Mule) Space Truckin’ (a/k/a "Smoke on the Infield" - really! look up the video for this one to see Ritchie's wild destruction that extended this to nearly 30 minutes)
Just a reminder that these are what LastFM thinks I should listen to, not necessarily what I think you should listen to.
1. Bob Marley - "Natural Mystic"
I know this song quite well, but this arrangement is very different. Much slower, more horns, and binghi drums. In fact, if this were the first version I heard, I'd say it was a rare misstep in the Marley ouvre. Not a great version of one of the best songs to come out of Jamaica.
2. David Coverdale - "Don't You Cry"
The former lead singer of Whitesnake and Deep Purple, so we have some arena-styled rock. I know people go nuts about this sort of thing, but this track is overblown and very much too sappy.
3. Duquende - "Tu Camisita De Flores (Tangos)"
A spot of flamenco, so there's no knowing what we'll get today. I'll be perfectly honest at this point and admit that I really don't know how to tell one flamenco vocalist from another, so he sounds alright.
4. Black Uhuru - "Sponji Reggae"
This is an atrocious-quality live version of the song, but the quality of the song itself can still come through. Michael Rose's vocals and the wonderfully supple melody behind him just work out perfectly. Shame it's recorded by a congenital halfwit, though.
5. Trelldom - "Sonar dreyri"
Trelldom was one of the first black metal acts I heard, and I remember it turned me off the style for ages. This track actually demonstrates exactly why - while it contains all of the features of a black metal track, it does precisely nothing with them for ten minutes. Boringness should be a crime.
6. Göksel - "Karar Verdim"
A bit more Turkish pop, again with a female vocalist. While the music is good, her voice doesn't suit it at all - she's gone with the "irritating little girl" sound for some reason. Not good.
7. Troll Collins - "Meet Ze Monsta"
Being a similar artist to That 1 Guy, this must at least be interesting music. Well, I'm not sure it is. He's got a half-hearted drum loop and a vocoder going on, but nothing is helping me like it.
8. Murat Boz - "Maximum"
Some more Turkish pop, and with a sort of hip-hop flavour to it. Decent music, and the vocalist is rather impressive. He's still just starting his career, it seems, although he should be bound for big things.
9. Gülşen - "Adı Aşk Sebebimin"
Female Turkish pop again. Rather derivative and boring.
10. Jose Merce - "Arrengao (Blues)"
And we finish with some flamenco. Well, flamenco that starts with a blues guitar and in fact sounds more as though it's from the Deep South than Iberia. It's an interesting idea, although I'm not sure it really works here.
Rush emerged at exactly the right time, becuase 1974 was otherwise not that strong of a year. It was a "gap" year for the might troika of Led Zeppelin, Black Sabbath, and Pink Floyd. Deep Purple did their part (see below). Eagles gave us one, but they weren't the powerhouse they were yet to become and it wasn't that strong; they actually spent the year finding their way along new direction that would be revealed the following summer.
But in a golden era of prog rock, I think there was a growing demand for something that more flat-out rocked with less complexity. Or maybe just a complementary alternative with less keyboards. That gap was filled with a number of great debuts and new styles. Some drew on the prevailing influences such as guitar-driven hard rock, some drew on progressive elements, some on the dark themes, and some even on glam. So, we had four debuts this year that would go on to heavily influence generations to come: Rush, Kiss, Judas Priest, and Bad Company. We also got the first album with what was the "real" Scorpions sound.
The debut by Rush though easily takes the award. This is hard rock Rush, and though they drew on progressive elements and quickly went that direction, this one is a more primal record. Rush broke out with this very album thanks to some help here in Cleveland, which I know I've mentioned before (more than once...) but thought the bragging rights were worth mentioning again as I credit this album as an AotY.
It's great to see multiple generations now at the shows of these rock elders. It's quite a different world now, though. These days the youngest generations aren't hearing this stuff broke via radio the way we did. They're discovering the classics like today's selection via video games, and this is having such a big impact that Rush gave Rock Band an alternate version of the song, and are even considering the possibility of selling a full album via Rock Band!
Selected other Red Dot tracks...these along with today's selection are all infrared dots:
Finding My Way: Was there ever such an awesome ear-grabbing opening track on a debut? (Oh, probably, it's just hyperbole...) But this one reels you in at first listen and tells you this band has immediate potential, and they never looked back. This is the kind of thing Led Zeppelin should have done with their debut: "Communication Breakdown" could have done the same immediate grab had they not buried it in the middle of side 2.
Here Again: A perfect song to put you into a reverie. I love to put this on the turntable and just watch the vinyl spin 'round while I lose myself in contemplation, and this song gets me there quick. One of my top ten Rush tracks and a previous SotD.
What You're Doing: Too bad more Alex Lifeson solos like this didn't remain a constant fixture all the way through the years! Great in-yer-face attitude lyrics, too, that tended to become more smoothed over in coming years. This song has probably my favorite Geddy Lee's vocals on the album.
Before And After: A nice mellow opening for the first couple of minutes, letting it build slowly to the rock and more great guitar work from Alex around 3:25. A nice way to lead into one final kick from today's album-closing selection.
--------
Rounding out the Top Five of 1974 (in order of descending RDF):
Scorpions: Fly to the Rainbow: Uli Jon Roth joins as Michael Schenker departs. Highlights of the album are in fact the contributions of Roth. Check out especially the album-closer title track, penned by Roth and Michael Schenker together. 71.4% RDF
KISS: Kiss: "What the hell is this?" everyone was thinking. But how could you not want to hear the music inside? And what a debut it was. In fact, in my personal collection, no other Kiss studio album matches it, and only Destroyer comes close. 70% RDF
Neil Young: On the Beach: Other Neil Young albums may have been stronger relative to this one, but in the weak year of 1974 for albums, this one rises near the top. The title track is shamefully underplayed. I've never even heard it on the radio, actually. Or any other song from this album, come to think of it. So maybe it's not so strong objectively, but it's still one of my favorite Neil Young albums. 62.5% RDF
If you've surfed through my SotD selections & stories on Deep Purple and Whitesnake, you'll see that I'm probably a bigger fan of the bluesy hard rock of Coverdale-era DP than the classic Mark II lineup, and an even bigger fan of the early Whitesnake (pre-Slide It In). Basically, David's first material up through the early 80s.
Today's selection is from his first solo material, released in 1977 in the wake of the dissolution of his era of Deep Purple. It's definitely a mixed bag, but he had early help from Mick Moody, and his guitar work basically saves some of the album, along with fine production assistance from Roger Glover.
The blues rock tracks are the best, but David must have been having some crisis of confidence after the DP breakup because he doesn't forge ahead in that direction as he would come to do with the band he would dub with a single-word version of the album name. A little bit too much soul on this album for me.