Progressive Rock for all types and ages » Discussões

Rush vs Dream Theater

Página 1 de 41 2 3 ...4 Próximo

- thewizard1989 disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 8 2007, 22h17
Rush vs Dream Theater

lets who is the best in this versus i prefer rush ll the way

The Sword Wields No Strenght Unless The Hand That Holds It Has Courage

[quote][b][user]thewizard1989[/user][/b] disse: lets who is the best in this versus i prefer rush ll the way [quote]

Permalink Citar
- Kaytos disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 9 2007, 13h09
I'd have to say I've always enjoyed Rush more.

[quote][b][user]Kaytos[/user][/b] disse: I'd have to say I've always enjoyed Rush more.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- TheYoki disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 9 2007, 13h32
RUSH!

Can't wait for the new album-

There is no dark side of the moon, really. As a matter of fact, it's all dark

[quote][b][user]TheYoki[/user][/b] disse: RUSH! Can't wait for the new album-[quote]

Permalink Citar
- cyberdrummer disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 9 2007, 17h33
Dream Theater.

[quote][b][user]cyberdrummer[/user][/b] disse: Dream Theater.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- DudeTheMath disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 9 2007, 18h38
I just finished listening to Rush in Rio, and it's simply awesome.

DT seems to have a better way with the "concept album", but Rush's music just seems more stirring. It's like comparing beethoven and Wagner, perhaps. Wagner paints these sweeping vistas, through-composing his operas with distinct leitmotifs, all perfectly crafted. Beethoven overall seems more able to compel the emotional response of the listener while not ignoring the intellectual stimulation.

[quote][b][user]DudeTheMath[/user][/b] disse: I just finished listening to [album artist=Rush]Rush In Rio[/album], and it's simply awesome. DT seems to have a better way with the "concept album", but Rush's music just seems more stirring. It's like comparing [artist]Beethoven[/artist] and [artist]Wagner[/artist], perhaps. Wagner paints these sweeping vistas, through-composing his operas with distinct leitmotifs, all perfectly crafted. Beethoven overall seems more able to compel the emotional response of the listener while not ignoring the intellectual stimulation.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- robi2000 disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 13 2007, 20h21
Rush!!!!!!!!

[quote][b][user]robi2000[/user][/b] disse: Rush!!!!!!!![quote]

Permalink Citar
- [Usuário excluído] disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 13 2007, 20h48
mmhh...I can't really say..I love them both..but maybe I put Dream Theater little over^^

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] disse: mmhh...I can't really say..I love them both..but maybe I put Dream Theater little over^^[quote]

Permalink Citar
- zam319 disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 15 2007, 23h02
Dream theater (even though I cant stant the singer)

[quote][b][user]zam319[/user][/b] disse: Dream theater (even though I cant stant the singer)[quote]

Permalink Citar
- real_doorshlaq disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 16 2007, 19h07
La Brie is great vocalist. I have seen DT live and it was unforgettable experience... But I love Rush just as much as DT.

[quote][b][user]real_doorshlaq[/user][/b] disse: La Brie is great vocalist. I have seen DT live and it was unforgettable experience... But I love Rush just as much as DT.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Watchful_Eye disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 17 2007, 0h32
Until last Christmas, I have just known Dream Theater.. but then I got The "Moving Pictures" and now Im sure I prefer Rush.. maybe DT is more complex but Rush has got more "soul" :-)

[quote][b][user]Watchful_Eye[/user][/b] disse: Until last Christmas, I have just known Dream Theater.. but then I got The "Moving Pictures" and now Im sure I prefer Rush.. maybe DT is more complex but Rush has got more "soul" :-)[quote]

Permalink Citar
- real_doorshlaq disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 19 2007, 11h48
I don't think Rush has got 'more soul'. I think that DT has it exactly as much as Rush :). Or even more... Try listening "Images and Words", "Scenes From a Memory" or "Octavarium". There CAN'T be more soul :)

[quote][b][user]real_doorshlaq[/user][/b] disse: I don't think Rush has got 'more soul'. I think that DT has it exactly as much as Rush :). Or even more... Try listening "Images and Words", "Scenes From a Memory" or "Octavarium". There CAN'T be more soul :)[quote]

Permalink Citar
- asdeafas disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 20 2007, 6h01
Ok... I've heard some songs by Dream Theater and only slightly more songs by Rush, but since the question is for my personal opinion I figure I can answer.
The amount of good songs by Dream Theater is highly limited. As far as I've heard none of the tracks with vocals are really good. They are so boring. Nothing happens.

On the other hand Rush also has a bunch of not so good songs. Basically most of their eighties stuff is quite horrid. I think it's the production/the sound of the instruments rather than the compositions in themselves that don't appeal to me.

But all in all I like Rush more, but, as I said, I've heard more Rush, so my opinion on DT might change...

...Weisst Du wer ich bin?

[quote][b][user]asdeafas[/user][/b] disse: Ok... I've heard some songs by Dream Theater and only slightly more songs by Rush, but since the question is for my personal opinion I figure I can answer. The amount of good songs by Dream Theater is highly limited. As far as I've heard none of the tracks with vocals are really good. They are so boring. Nothing happens. On the other hand Rush also has a bunch of not so good songs. Basically most of their eighties stuff is quite horrid. I think it's the production/the sound of the instruments rather than the compositions in themselves that don't appeal to me. But all in all I like Rush more, but, as I said, I've heard more Rush, so my opinion on DT might change...[quote]

Permalink Citar
- [Usuário excluído] disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 26 2007, 17h16
Well, I'd say Rush.. Especially since Rush has influenced Dream Theater.
Besides, I personally enjoy Rush a little more. Dream Theater are still one of my top bands.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] disse: Well, I'd say Rush.. Especially since Rush has influenced Dream Theater. Besides, I personally enjoy Rush a little more. Dream Theater are still one of my top bands. [quote]

Permalink Citar
- pirate_pRT disse...
- Usuário
- Fev 28 2007, 14h08
i say Dream Theaterwin

[quote][b][user]pirate_pRT[/user][/b] disse: i say [artist]Dream Theater [/artist]win[quote]

Permalink Citar
- real_doorshlaq disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 1 2007, 19h05
Now i realised that this topic is rather stupid. How can you decide which of the two wonderful bands is better?

[quote][b][user]real_doorshlaq[/user][/b] disse: Now i realised that this topic is rather stupid. How can you decide which of the two wonderful bands is better?[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Eleniel disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 2 2007, 14h08
Dream Theater. I don't like Rush.

[quote][b][user]Eleniel[/user][/b] disse: [artist]Dream Theater[/artist]. I don't like [artist]Rush[/artist].[quote]

Permalink Citar
- hoheyt disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 2 2007, 15h25
boo for Rush, DT!

[quote][b][user]hoheyt[/user][/b] disse: boo for Rush, DT![quote]

Permalink Citar
- Sgt_Pompous disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 3 2007, 0h53
Rush all the way

[quote][b][user]Sgt_Pompous[/user][/b] disse: Rush all the way[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Watchful_Eye disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 22 2007, 23h21
real_doorshlaq said:
I don't think Rush has got 'more soul'. I think that DT has it exactly as much as Rush :). Or even more... Try listening "Images and Words", "Scenes From a Memory" or "Octavarium". There CAN'T be more soul :)

Hmm from these Albums I just know "Images and Words", and for me it is Music that tries to be very warm or emotional, but it isnt. Especially the Ballads..
with sax, bombast and whatever.. it sounds cold to me.

And thats for me even more problematic, because it sounds not.. "honest" .. my mostly-liked Song of DT is "Erotomania".. although it sounds as one of the coldest, I think it is one of the few Songs of them which really transport some kind of atmosphere. (Hard to explain, I hope you know what I mean ;-) ).

[quote][b][user]Watchful_Eye[/user][/b] disse: [quote][b][user]real_doorshlaq[/user][/b] said: I don't think Rush has got 'more soul'. I think that DT has it exactly as much as Rush :). Or even more... Try listening "Images and Words", "Scenes From a Memory" or "Octavarium". There CAN'T be more soul :)[/quote] Hmm from these Albums I just know "Images and Words", and for me it is Music that tries to be very warm or emotional, but it isnt. Especially the Ballads.. with sax, bombast and whatever.. it sounds cold to me. And thats for me even more problematic, because it sounds not.. "honest" .. my mostly-liked Song of DT is "Erotomania".. although it sounds as one of the coldest, I think it is one of the few Songs of them which really transport some kind of atmosphere. (Hard to explain, I hope you know what I mean ;-) ).[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Stratmaster disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 26 2007, 20h43
Dream Theater.
But I like Rush too.

[quote][b][user]Stratmaster[/user][/b] disse: Dream Theater. But I like Rush too.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- BriansHalfbaked disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 30 2007, 19h01
Rush
I think Dream Theater Sux

[quote][b][user]BriansHalfbaked[/user][/b] disse: Rush I think Dream Theater Sux[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Kjekssjokolade disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 31 2007, 13h23
Rush, of course. Rush is the best of these two bands, without a doubt. I don't like their 80s stuff, but the rest is rocking the free world!

I don't like Dream Theater, the music don't just fall in my taste range. Even tough they are good musicians, I would say they don't fit so good together (dream theater that is), don't like their compositions, lyrics, or the voice of the lead singer.

[quote][b][user]Kjekssjokolade[/user][/b] disse: Rush, of course. Rush is the best of these two bands, without a doubt. I don't like their 80s stuff, but the rest is rocking the free world! I don't like Dream Theater, the music don't just fall in my taste range. Even tough they are good musicians, I would say they don't fit so good together (dream theater that is), don't like their compositions, lyrics, or the voice of the lead singer. [quote]

Permalink Citar
- crazy_starkid disse...
- Usuário
- Mar 31 2007, 22h57
I can't choose only one of my two favourites bands, but all DT albums are incredibles... Ok, vote for Dream theater

[quote][b][user]crazy_starkid[/user][/b] disse: I can't choose only one of my two favourites bands, but all DT albums are incredibles... Ok, vote for Dream theater[quote]

Permalink Citar
- karlsson_666 disse...
- Usuário
- Abr 3 2007, 17h56
To all you that dont like the 80s stuff, give it more time.

And I like Rush more.

[quote][b][user]karlsson_666[/user][/b] disse: To all you that dont like the 80s stuff, give it more time. And I like Rush more.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- [Usuário excluído] disse...
- Usuário
- Abr 12 2007, 20h27
I hate rush so its safe for me to say that DT is way better.

[quote][b][user][/user][/b] disse: I hate rush so its safe for me to say that DT is way better.[quote]

Permalink Citar