Question tagging live tracks for 2 albums from 1 band...

- maplejet disse...
- Usuário
- Set 11 2009, 18h09
Question tagging live tracks for 2 albums from 1 band...

What if a band has more than 2 live releases and has performed one song live on many of the live releases.

For example (Hypothetical)

There is a band called Kokl, and they have a song called Bold that was performed live on multiple albums, let's say this.

Live Album 1 (was in Detroit, United States on 5/1/2005)
Live Album 2 (was in London, England 8/13/2007)
Live Album 3 (was in Sydney, Australia, 3/6/2009)

How would you tag this track "Bold" for each of the albums? Simply 3 "Bold (live)" tracks, or is there a specific way of writing it.

LAST WEEK:

RIP Michael Jackson (1958-2009)
May your soul rest in peace.

[quote][b][user]maplejet[/user][/b] disse: What if a band has more than 2 live releases and has performed one song live on many of the live releases. For example (Hypothetical) There is a band called [b]Kokl[/b], and they have a song called [b]Bold[/b] that was performed live on multiple albums, let's say this. [b]Live Album 1[/b] (was in Detroit, United States on 5/1/2005) [b]Live Album 2[/b] (was in London, England 8/13/2007) [b]Live Album 3[/b] (was in Sydney, Australia, 3/6/2009) How would you tag this track "Bold" for each of the albums? Simply 3 "Bold (live)" tracks, or is there a specific way of writing it.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- OrdinaryDreams disse...
- Assinante
- Set 12 2009, 12h56
Just tag them with Band - Song Name (Live) imo, specific tags for each live performance will really add up in the long run

[quote][b][user]OrdinaryDreams[/user][/b] disse: Just tag them with [i]Band - Song Name (Live)[/i] imo, specific tags for each live performance will really add up in the long run[quote]

Permalink Citar
- D5FA disse...
- Usuário
- Set 13 2009, 1h05
I have 15 tracks by Morrissey called Suedehead (live) [I use a small first letter for live, acoustic, demo, alternate mix etc.] all from different nights over 20 years haha

[quote][b][user]D5FA[/user][/b] disse: I have 15 tracks by Morrissey called Suedehead (live) [I use a small first letter for live, acoustic, demo, alternate mix etc.] all from different nights over 20 years haha[quote]

Permalink Citar
- Neowulf disse...
- Usuário
- Set 16 2009, 9h13
If it's on a live album, simply "Kokl - Bold" without any additional qualifier. Redundant to mark every song on a live album as live. And which album it is on tells which version it is.

I used to tag so that every Artist - Title combination was unique, but with a good media library application it isn't necessary and just look messy in the long run.

[quote][b][user]Neowulf[/user][/b] disse: If it's on a live album, simply "Kokl - Bold" without any additional qualifier. Redundant to mark every song on a live album as live. And which album it is on tells which version it is. I used to tag so that every Artist - Title combination was unique, but with a good media library application it isn't necessary and just look messy in the long run.[quote]

Permalink Citar
- terriphin disse...
- Usuário
- Set 21 2009, 23h13
neowulf is right on...i have every concert the grateful dead played, so that's hundreds of versions of songs, i think it would be pointless to mark them all as, for example, Help On The Way (live) 110 times.

The wheel is turning and you can't slow down

[quote][b][user]terriphin[/user][/b] disse: neowulf is right on...i have every concert the grateful dead played, so that's hundreds of versions of songs, i think it would be pointless to mark them all as, for example, Help On The Way (live) 110 times. [quote]

Permalink Citar
- unnami disse...
- Assinante
- Nov 9 2009, 22h35
I tag this for this example:
artist: Kokl
title: Bold
album: Detroit, United States on 5/1/2005

What's the point of having it all without the person you love. Sometimes you just need to start again in order to fly.

[quote][b][user]unnami[/user][/b] disse: I tag this for this example: artist: Kokl title: Bold album: Detroit, United States on 5/1/2005 [quote]

Permalink Citar

Usuários anônimos não podem postar mensagens. É preciso fazer login ou criar uma conta para postar nos fóruns.