Crypto-Fascists » Discussões

Black crypto metal?

 
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 14 2007, 10h48

    Black crypto metal?

    So in another thread the question was asked rather a band like Marduk must be considered cryptofa. For they aren't speaking about nazism but their album names and songs are pointing towards it.

    What about bands like Darkthrone, Dissection, Dark Funeral and so on? And where is the line between Black crypto Metal and NSBM?

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 14 2007, 12h32
    This is not so easy to determine. While there are bands like Absurd who are openly National Socialist, there are many bands who play mostly (neo)pagan metal, like the wonderful Темнозорь from Russia. Yet their members are neonazis. Then there are bands like Graveland and perhaps even Drudkh, whose music contains little to no references to nazism, yet whose members very likely are neonazis of some kind.

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 14 2007, 17h06
    Yes that's true, but that's the same with my band. Me and the other Guitarplayer are both left winged. The drummer has no opinion and the Singer is rather right-winged, although he told me last week that he became softer since he knew me. But anyhow, we don't talk/sing/yell about politics in our songs, so that kind of bands will always be there.

    But can you name me some blackmetal bands that seem NSBM but aren't? Like with their images or song/bandnames?

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 14 2007, 18h34
    Well, that Marduk comes to mind, but I'm not familiar with them. I don't really no any others, but there should be some bands like that. It seems, however, that usually when a metal band has a nazi image, it is some kind of a declaration of ideology...

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 16 2007, 10h52
    Well, I'm more into deathmetal and in that genre I can name a few like: Panzerchrist, Dies Irae and Vader (as a matter of fact alot of Polish bands...)

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 16 2007, 15h39
    I can't believe I forgot about Loits. They fit the cryptofa image prefectly; they talk about WWII and Estonia's part in it, and even dress as Estonian SS soldiers in their album art. Yet they are by no means nazis or the like, they simply use the WWII-era imagery to rise discussion about a part of Estonian history.

    Editado por um usuário excluído em Mar 18 2007, 21h41
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 18 2007, 19h29
    Added them to our artists connections

    • monjolo disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 20 2007, 12h54
    Yep, I was going to suggest Loits too. Cryptofa to the bone.

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 27 2007, 23h33
    I think, to come back on the cryptometal, that many death and black metal bands make use of nazi symbols. Even Motörhead could be concidered cryptofa, if you pure look at their images. (iron crosses, the lettering etc.) But many deathmetal bands like Vader, Dies Irae (mainly Polish bands) and more Nu-metal from the states. Panzerchrist from Denmark is a great example. They have recorded albums in German, only sing about the second world war and their images can be concidered nazi-like. But they claim that they aren't right winged at all. Are the lying? Or are they cryptofa to the bone? ;)

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 29 2007, 16h22
    Gorebatjov said:
    But they claim that they aren't right winged at all. Are the lying? Or are they cryptofa to the bone? ;)


    Well, I think that it comes down to whether or not they are right wing. If they are, but are for some reason lying about it by saying that they aren't, then they aren't cryptofa. But if they indeed aren't right wing and have no special pro-Nazi sentiments, then they are cryptofa, at least based on your description. (I don't know the band myself).

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mar 29 2007, 21h10
    Yes, I was thinking the same. It still makes me think, I've read many interviews with them, but they always seem to keep their political views in the shadow side. The only thing they claimed, is that they won't write albums in German again, because of the bad reviews. (people who were thinking they were right winged/nazi) But is that a commercial step, or does it mean they aren'r rightwinged?

    Sorry, I'm still questioning myself, I know ;) It's just an interesting band. For the link: Panzerchrist

  • You could add Skyforger to the artist connections.They use swatikas but they are just Pagans.

    Libera me domine de morte,aetema in die illa tremenda.
    http://uwww.last.fm/group/Neofolk+Against+Racism
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Abr 23 2007, 10h25
    Added ;)

    • sebbo_nl disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 3 2007, 3h52
    You could debate about adding ZZ-Top as well. I mean, look at their logo. Isn't that "ZZ" just an SS-rune turned round?
    Lots of bands use/used WWII/nazi imagery, without ever mentioning politics in their songs.

    The rules of coping with me:
    1. I am on medication. What's your excuse?
    2. I resent the term "hypocrite". I'd rather be called "morally ambivalent".
    3. In my little world, I'm always right!
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 3 2007, 10h08
    Like Kiss who even didn't take the efford to turn around the SS-rune, but made a nice shiny symbol of it, with lightbulbs in it ;)

  • Hmm,add Kawir.They are a great Greek Black Metal band that sings about Hellenic culture,religion and traditions.Nevertheless,they are not right-winged.

    Libera me domine de morte,aetema in die illa tremenda.
    http://uwww.last.fm/group/Neofolk+Against+Racism
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 29 2007, 1h14
    angahir said:
    I can't believe I forgot about Loits. They fit the cryptofa image prefectly; they talk about WWII and Estonia's part in it, and even dress as Estonian SS soldiers in their album art. Yet they are by no means nazis or the like, they simply use the WWII-era imagery to rise discussion about a part of Estonian history.


    They're a pretty good band also.

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 29 2007, 8h58

    Burzum... Nazi or not?

    So... the shoutbox was filled with comments about Burzum. According to my information Burzum isn't a nazi or rascist band, but bandleader Varg is. On the other hand am I not a big fan of , so my info insn't everything.

    Someone else knows what's the real deal behind Burzum?

  • Well, Burzum's lyrics are no way racist or nazistic. That's sure. And for Varg. He denies being a National Socialist (Nazi). He is racist and that's sure but he is not a Nazi. And that's because Varg beliefs are contradicted to Nazis. Varg admires Slavic history and its people whereas Nazi hated them. Varg is not a Socialist whereas Nazis are. That's the differences. He is right-winged and he had led various right-wing organizations that had been alleged to be Neo-Nazi but its members claimed not to be racist. Varg is also and Odinist and not a Wotanist whilst Wotanism is Nazi at nature but Odinism not.

    Libera me domine de morte,aetema in die illa tremenda.
    http://uwww.last.fm/group/Neofolk+Against+Racism
  • To conclude, Burzum should be here.

    Libera me domine de morte,aetema in die illa tremenda.
    http://uwww.last.fm/group/Neofolk+Against+Racism
  • There is also a bunch of Black Metal bands that have lyrics about anti-Judeo-Christianity. They are heavily anti-Christian. Whilst not being Nazi or anything or not even racist they are deeply against Jesus and Abrahamic religions. Such bands are Silencer and Grand Belial's Key.

    Libera me domine de morte,aetema in die illa tremenda.
    http://uwww.last.fm/group/Neofolk+Against+Racism
    • EBM_Head disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 29 2007, 17h08
    Even that Nazi means Nationalsozialist, most Nazis are very against any kind of socialist ideas. In early Nazigermany there have been leftwing Nazis, like the SA, the NSBO, the Strasser Brothers and even the sneaky Goebbels (who later changed side). Those was fighting for better working conditions, against unemployment and mostly weren't antisemitic. But around 30th June 1934 they all have been eliminated or put to silience. After that only the rightwing Nazis did rule and everything became more nationalistic, antisemitic, racistic and totalitarian. Today it isn't any different: There are lots of unemployed people or some of the lowest worker class that are very dissappointed of the socialist movement, that vote right wing parties because they think if someone kicks out all foreigners they would have better chances in life. Thats what those rightwing partys preach, but they don't have any interrest in doing any social changes for the better of the working class. All they are up to is rebuilding a racist totalitarian regime with all it's corruption and nepotism that comes along to such system.

    Another interresting term is Fascism. The italian fascist movement was in the beginning an anticommunist/antisocialist, conservative, patriotic and antiwar (!) movement. It later became step by step authoritarian, nationalistic, rascistic, expansive and antisemitic and thats why the word fascism has a bad smell nowadadays.

    I better stop, as this thread is about Black Metal and not about politics...


    Free download of the Maolympic Games Sampler @ Archive.org
    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 30 2007, 2h55
    I'm not sure about the use of Nazi and Fascist aesthetic in metal. Coming from experience spent with significant amount of time exploring this side of metal, I don't think that a lot of metal bands adopt fascist aethetic out of an anti-fascist political statement, than to be regarded as 'more extreme', or alternatively, they actually believe in their purported fascism.

    It's really nothing like the kind of 'Crypto-fascism' as defined in the Manifesto as written.

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 31 2007, 0h58
    Well, I'm in the metalscene to and I don't see a lot of bands who actually 'preach' fascism or national socialism in their songs, but are (extreme) right winged as persons. I think most of the metal musicians don't really have the urge to add politics to their lyrics. Maybe it's getting to complicated for them if they did ;)

    • [Usuário excluído] disse...
    • Usuário
    • Mai 31 2007, 4h07
    Well honestly, outside of the NSBM scene (particularly the stuff that's been coming out of Ukraine of all places in the last decade or so, like Temnozor, Dub Buk, Nokturnal Mortum), Slayer (occasionally), some of the bands associated with the late Vinland Winds Records, etc. and the very important exception of Loits, you don't see a lot of overt fascist aesthetic in metal, at least not nearly on the same kind of scale that one would find in NON, Laibach or Death In June. You'll see a lot of right-winged rednecks, roleplaying-freaks and/or neopagans deluded to think that they're vikings, but hardly any that use fascist aesthetic as an artistic statement.

    From experience in the metalscene anyway.

Usuários anônimos não podem postar mensagens. É preciso fazer login ou criar uma conta para postar nos fóruns.